Skip to Content
 

Expert reference for my school project?

6 replies [Last post]
Anonymous

I'm 15 years old, from the UK, a big fan of tabletop gaming. For my GCSE Graphics coursework, I have to design and construct a board game that involves some 3D aspect. Part of the coursework involves evidence of expert advice. Rather than send a letter off to any of the big board game companies and get no reply, I thought talking to an internet community of dedicated individuals such as yourselves would be far more a realistic option.
I'd be really grateful if you could help me out, just by being available for a few questions via email.
Thanks for reading,

Sam

Yekrats
Offline
Joined: 08/11/2008
Expert reference for my school project?

Well, you can easily (?) add a 3D element to a game by having some sort of stackable element to a game that already has a width and breadth component. Abstractly, some of the Gipf games do this. I'm also thinking about Torres, Tikal to a certain extent, and others. I'll bet there are wargames out there that take into account 3D action, however I'm not a grognard and don't know much about those things any more.

But your assignment is hard! I have prototyped probably 20 games or so in my life, and I can only think of one which had 3D features. I don't know how well I would perform if someone assigned such a task to me. Tough, tough assignment. Maybe I'll think about it a bit more, now that you mentioned it.

I'm afraid I haven't been much help, but I would be available if you wanted to ask more questions, and I wish you the best of luck!
-- Scott S.

Anonymous
Expert reference for my school project?

I'm not sure I count as an expert (I've been in game retail for about... 10 years) but I'd thought I'd throw out some games, too. Dvonn (the Gipf game Scott mentioned), Tikal, and Fish Eat Fish all use stacking pieces to make them worth more points or more powerful.

An older game called Terrace uses a 3d board, higher pieces can capture lower pieces. I think the box still says "As Seen on Star Trek!" even though the show's been dead for over a decade now. A few companies have made 3d versions of tic tac toe and chess. Ehh :roll:.

HeroClix uses a mild 3d element. Some of the heros "fly" and go up on a little plastic stilts and interact with the other heros differently.

Pylos is the best example I can think of: a 3d game that really uses the 3d aspect. Here's the boardgamegeek link. Ooo... looking at what Gigmatic has made, I found a few others - Batik (good example) and Quivive (not so good). Batik reminded me of probably the most obvious example of a game with a 3d element, Blockhead.

This has been fun. I should make a test for my staff. Name three games that use a 3d element! Go! Anyways, in my expert :wink: opinion, only a few games use a 3d element, but most use it as a record keeping device (Tikal, Fish Eat Fish, Terrace, Dvonn, etc). Only a few games take full advantage of it (Blockhead and Pylos).

-Sean

phpbbadmin
Offline
Joined: 04/23/2013
Also

The game Dragon Delta makes use of 3 dimensional elements, although in kind of a 2 dimensional way.

-Darke

Scurra
Scurra's picture
Offline
Joined: 09/11/2008
Expert reference for my school project?

The best example I can think of is Pueblo which uses blocks to construct a building but has a lovely tactical element added which makes the placement of the blocks significant.

And then there's always Jenga (the classic) and Villa Paletti if you want the pure 3d component.

(in other words, don't be afraid of thinking about a game that only works in three dimensions...)

FastLearner
Offline
Joined: 12/31/1969
Expert reference for my school project?

My favorite boardgame that uses the third dimension is Java, and the 3D aspect is pretty tightly interwoven into the game, I feel. This picture kind of shows the 3D aspect. It's definitely a boardgame where you have to think in all 3 dimensions in order to win.

FastLearner
Offline
Joined: 12/31/1969
Expert reference for my school project?

In fact, here's an excellent list of 3D boardgames with pictures and links to more information.

I just knew someone had already created such a list: the odds were simply too good. :)

-- Matthew

Syndicate content


forum | by Dr. Radut