Week 3: Project Postings
This week has no readings, and instead only the blog/lesson and an exercise. The Discussion thread will be reserved for critique of the entries listed here, following the guidelines set up in this week's lesson: describing the game's formal elements, critical questions about challenge, interaction, fairness, replayability, etc.
I also want to state that if there are too few replies in this week (I'd say four or more, myself included, is a reasonable request), I'll step back from posting these messages for now, and pick it up sometime later in the year should interest in these lessons resurface.
Follow this link to the blog:
https://gamedesignconcepts.wordpress.com/2009/07/06/level-3-formal-eleme...
There are three levels of challenge for this week's exercise. Start with the Green Circle, then advance to Blue Square, then finally Black Diamond... Whichever you feel would be most worth your time.
Green Circle
The theme must relate to World War I. The primary objective of players cannot be territorial control, or capture/destroy.
Blue Square
You cannot use territorial control or capture/destroy as game dynamics. That is, your game is not allowed to contain the concepts of territory or death in any form.
Black Diamond
As above, and the players may not engage in direct conflict, only indirect.
Post your rules summaries in this thread. Have fun!!!
I did more research and reading about The Great War today than I think I had during all my high school years combined...That's not saying much for public education, I admit, but it made today's reading quite an adventure.
I decided to focus on a more personal aspect of WW1: families being uprooted from their homes and forced to go elsewhere. I'm thinking Serbia or Austria-Hungary, or even Russia would be worthwhile settings for this. The main idea is that players must collect escape supplies (the cards) from different shared locations in town (the board), and then use those supplies to plot their escape. There is more competition than conflict between players in this game. The player who makes it to a safehouse and has the most pawnable valuables wins.
The game is divided into two phases.
PHASE 1: SCAVENGE
This represents the players rummaging through their homes and nearby abandoned buildings in a last-ditch effort to find supplies or travel companions they can use to travel to another - hopefully safer - home. The master deck of Scavenge Cards is shuffled, and they're dealt between several different locations, each having its own small stack of 6 or so cards. Players visit their home location first, and can select a certain number of cards from that stack to keep. The remaining cards are then removed, and the building has been emptied of useful objects or party members. A building with no cards cannot be chosen to be searched again.
To search the next building, the players must choose one or more cards from their current hand, and discard them. The value of the discarded card(s) indicates how many cards they may collect from the next building they search. This represents the resources used to sneak in unseen by, negotiate with, or overpower the residents and guards in the building.
This phase would end when there were no more buildings to search. If there are fewer buildings remaining than players, silent auction and bidding of resources from the players' current hands will determine who is allowed in, with the highest bidders gaining access to remaining buildings. As a consolation, those who are unable to enter buildings are welcome to take the top card from the Scavenge Discard.
PHASE 2: FLIGHT
Now the resources collected in Phase 1 must be used to "buy" aspects of escape for Phase 2.
A game mat indicates different steps along the journey, along with cards that are drawn from an Escape Deck (I cringe to use the words "Flight Deck," since that has a completely different meaning...). Players do silent auction bidding like done in Phase 1 for determining who enters the last buildings. They bid on these cards to earn Escape Points (EP), and when a player reaches a certain number of EP, they advance on the Escape Route towards the Rendezvous/escape location.
Bids would have one required resource in addition to a set number of resources beyond that. For example, one card could have "Fuel + 5," which would mean that a Fuel card is required, along with 5 miscellaneous resources. Those who have the required resource(s) would receive preference for winning the bid. Objects of wealth - jewelry, rare books, and assorted rich stuff - would stand in for these required resources but at the cost of increasing the miscellaneous cost for that player.
The player mat has space for several Escape Cards to be shown at once, but cards are bid for only one at a time, the "cheapest" or lowest-value card first.
There is also a danger that can end the game prematurely. Invader Cards are shuffled into the Escape Deck, and whenever one of them is drawn, they are placed on the Escape Route starting with the space furthest away from the Rendezvous. If the player's counter is on the same space as an Invader Card, they must either stop their progress or immediately bribe the guard. Resource cards would be discarded equal or greater to the Invader Card value to continue.
Play would continue until all players have reached the Rendezvous or have been captured by Invaders. Point values are added up: all cards collected and remaining from Phase 1 and 2. The player with the most points overall wins the game.
ABOUT THE CHARACTERS
I also think it's important to focus on the personalized aspect of the game, and for that I wanted to create characters/personas the players would select at the game start. These could range from typical archetypes or even more complex character sketches, or the player could even build their own character on a point-based system of "perks" and "faults."
A first iteration would be something as simple as the different passengers in Jeff Siadek's Lifeboat:
http://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/4174/lifeboat
Later iterations would likely go more towards the cinematic, as in Last Night on Earth:
http://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/29368/last-night-earth-zombie-game
The main takeaway is that each character could do something a little different than the others. Or, in the case of a player being able to develop their own character, they craft their abilities in the fashion they want. Perks and Faults could be indicated with cards laid down on a character mat, so there's no duplication between characters in any one game.
SOME EXAMPLE SCAVENGE CARDS
Warm Clothing
Fuel
Pitchfork
Pistol
Hunting Rifle
Gold Pocketwatch
Gold & Emerald Ring
Rope
Pack Horse
Resistance Fighter
Messenger Boy
Hiking Boots
Each card would have a certain value for Phase 1, allowing the player to draw additional cards when Scavenging additional buildings. There would also be some nuance and special effects added to some of the cards:
- Draw extra cards during Phase 1
- Worth an extra 2 miscellaneous resources in Phase 2
- Eliminate an Invader card instead of placing on Escape Route in Phase 2
- If used to enter a building in Phase 1, add to the stack of cards on another building instead of discard
- Search the discarded Scavenge Cards and replace it with this card
Cards with special effects would generally be worth less Escape value, to balance the special effect with their use during bidding. The general strategy would be to populate a player's hand with low-value Scavenge cards, with the expectation they'll be able to advance their position or "trade up" at some point later in the game.
SOME EXAMPLE ESCAPE CARDS
Safehouse
Motorcycle
Sewer Tunnel
Secret Room
Underground Railroad
Smoke Grenade
These would have Escape Point values, allowing the player to move along the Escape Route towards the Rendezvous/end.