Hi guys I could use some feedback on a card game I'm making
https://drive.google.com/folderview?id=0BxaUbqjP_RAjdENjNDBBc1hWT1E
It's a mix between hearthstone Carcassonne and magic the gathering
Hi guys I could use some feedback on a card game I'm making
https://drive.google.com/folderview?id=0BxaUbqjP_RAjdENjNDBBc1hWT1E
It's a mix between hearthstone Carcassonne and magic the gathering
I usually lose interest as soon as Hearthstone or MTG is mentioned.
People who like TCGs are likely playing one already. Or stopped playing one and moved on to something else.
You won't be able to compete if you go for the same niche. TCGs require constant influx of new content to remain interesting. And influx of new content requires constant extensive testing by a dedicated team working on it full time.
If you are absolutely adamant at making an MTG clone it would be a good idea to not describe it as a "a mix between hearthstone Carcassonne and magic the gathering". Instead, describe how it's _not_ like any other game.
I know this might sound harsh, but that's the best feedback I can give you.
Things seem very bare-bones to me at the moment.
Have you playtested any of this at all? How have your playtests been? What sort of feedback have you had from others - if any - who have seen this on the table? Failing that, have you done any solo testing yet? What works really well?
Generally speaking, I would caution you against adding any more moving parts to the game before some significant testing is done. I gather that you're asking the player to manage their hand of cards, their mana/energy and HP, followed by a map made up of tiles with their units scattered all across it. This is a lot for the typical player to manage all at once, in my opinion.
This seems like an ambitious project! Best of success with it, Sprutnums. :)
![]() | PoA — Improving the Design (21) by questccg |
![]() | Winner Announced for VHS Case Challenge! (0) by The Game Crafter |
![]() | What are "Factions"??? Are they UNITS per Faction or something else??? (35) by X3M |
![]() | 1d6 is all you need (4) by X3M |
![]() | Game Designer's Ruler (0) by The Game Crafter |
![]() | New Staff Pick at The Game Crafter - The Fall of Oakhaven (0) by The Game Crafter |
![]() | Board Game Blueprint - New Episode Every Wednesday (41) by The Game Crafter |
![]() | New Board Game Pieces - Premium Deflector Shield & Premium Trash Can (0) by The Game Crafter |
![]() | Walls? To give cover, or not to give cover? (21) by X3M |
![]() | Sir Thecos Unboxes 7 Tabletop Games from The Game Crafter (0) by The Game Crafter |
![]() | Tariffs and The Game Crafter (3) by larienna |
![]() | Game design project management platforms (2) by X3M |
![]() | Trying to Learn to use Vassal (5) by larienna |
![]() | Protospiel Kansas City 2025 (0) by The Game Crafter |
![]() | Do-It-Yourself Dice Kit (0) by The Game Crafter |
![]() | Cinco De Mayo Sale at The Game Crafter (0) by The Game Crafter |
![]() | What generic prototype components are worth keeping? (3) by X3M |
![]() | Bulk Order Queue Update (0) by The Game Crafter |
![]() | Toy Business Unboxed Podcast - The Power of Personal Branding with JT Smith, The Willy Wonka of Tabletop Industry (1) by questccg |
![]() | Proto ATL 2025 - Started Today! (0) by The Game Crafter |
![]() | Protospiel Indy 2025 (0) by sirvalence |
![]() | New Board Game Pieces - Premium Pile of Bones & Premium Tentacle (0) by The Game Crafter |
![]() | Kingdom of ... (12) by questccg |
![]() | PoA — Major shift back closer to FCE (17) by questccg |
![]() | Solo racing game: Stunt racing (5) by larienna |
This is like the best feedback i have gotten so far. Be original - dont make clones